2020

The Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Higher Education (Pell Institute) at the Council for Opportunity in Education (COE) and the Alliance for Higher Education and Democracy at the University of Pennsylvania (PennAHEAD) are pleased to announce the publication of the Indicators of Higher Education Equity in the United States — 2020 Historical Trend Report. We are also pleased to welcome you to the Equity Indicators Website. The Indicators Reports and this website are dedicated to the shared missions of the Pell Institute and PennAHEAD to foster a U.S. higher education system in which all citizens, regardless of family backgrounds, have the opportunity to develop their talents and capacity to fully participate in a democratic society.

This 2020 Indicators Report and the earlier reports compile historical statistical data from the nationally representative government statistics including the Census Bureau household studies and the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES)-sponsored high school and college longitudinal studies. These series track college entrance and completion by family income, socioeconomic status, and race/ethnicity. The 2018 to 2020 Indicator reports also include data on state variation in related statistics. The Indicators Reports present data as far back as comparable data warrant, often beginning with 1970. Methodological appendices provide additional relevant notes, tables, and figures.

Website Overview. The Equity Indicators Website allows policymakers, educators, and the public to explore data on equality and opportunity in U.S. higher education. It is our hope that the website will also provide a forum for dialogue and co-learning of the ways in which we can together foster greater inclusiveness and equity of educational opportunity within higher education in the United States. The Equity Indicators Website provides:

  • Downloadable Complete Reports for the 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020 reports.
  • Excel data files used to produce each of the figures included in the Indicators Reports.
  • Shared Solutions Essays that periodically accompany the reports.
  • New 2020 Infographics and Interactive Data Tool. Throughout 2020, we will be adding to the Indicators Website additional data visualizations and infographic stories.

A Special Focus on Understanding Equity. Each edition of the Indicators Reports has included a quote from the foreword to President Truman’s 1947 Commission on Higher Education that called attention to the dangers of a higher education system that functioned not to provide opportunity but to sort students:
“If the ladder of educational opportunity rises high at the doors of some youth and scarcely rises at the doors of others, while at the same time formal education is made a prerequisite to occupational and social advance, then education may become the means, not of eliminating race and class distinctions, but of deepening and solidifying them.”
The Indicators Reports are dedicated to increasing our understanding of how to address the equity issues raised by the Truman Commission Report 70 years ago.

Operationalizing Measures of Higher Education Opportunity in the United States. In these statistical reports, we operationalize the concept of “equity” in terms of several types of deviations from a distribution that would indicate “equal access to education.” For example, we observe the differences across quartiles of family income in the percentages of students entering college and receiving bachelor’s degrees. We also observe the extent to which, for example, the racial/ethnic distribution of the composition of the U.S. population differs from the racial/ethnic distribution of degree recipients.

The Search for Solutions Shared Dialogues. In addition to providing longitudinal indicators of equity, the reports are intended to advance productive conversation about effective policies and practices for improving equity in higher education opportunity and outcomes. To this end, we include periodic essays that connect the indicators to current policy debates or provide detailed examination of a relevant topic. We hope that the indicators and essays promote productive dialogue about how to create meaningful improvements in higher education equity.

2020 Essays. In-light of the public health COVID-19 pandemic which has upended much of everyone’s lives in the spring of 2020, a concluding “What Does it Mean?” section to the 2020 report, includes two new essays entitled:

  • Will the Dual Crises of Climate Change and the COVID-19 Pandemic be Portals to Widening Opportunity or Will the Doors Close Even Tighter? Strategies for a More Equitable, Resilient, and Ecologically Sustainable US Higher Education System, and
  • Where Do We Go from Here? Reflections on the Impact of COVID-19 and Higher Education from Two Recent TRIO Graduates

The 2020 Indicators Report, the Equity Indicators Website, and the accompanying Search for Solutions Shared Dialogues are made possible with support from Lumina Foundation and Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF). While we heartily acknowledge their support, any errors of omission or interpretation and the opinions expressed in the reports are the sole responsibility of the authors.

Highlights from the 2020 Report as included in a press release are below.



Report: Higher Education System at Critical Crossroads

Pandemic Reveals Can No Longer Turn Away from the Underlying Equity Issues Tracked in the Historical Trend Reports, Need Bold Ambitious Plans to Rebuild a System that is More Equitable, Resilient, and Ecologically Sustainable

WASHINGTON, D.C. (May 2020) — The COVID-19 pandemic has created a crisis across higher education, for both institutions and learners. But these new challenges are coming to rest on old inequalities that kept many low and middle-income Americans from attending college or earning a degree.

The 2020 Indicators of Higher Education Equity in the United States details this uneven landscape that is influenced by family income and history, geography, a wide range of state policies, and the declining value of federal student aid. The report shows that paying for college has never been harder, and those who attend are more likely to leave burdened with debt, whether or not they graduate. The report, building on a series, is published jointly by the Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Education of the Council for Opportunity in Education (COE), and the University of Pennsylvania Alliance for Higher Education and Democracy (PennAHEAD).

The lowest income students in the United States face great obstacles paying for college and the impact of the COVID-19 epidemic may compound the uncertainty such students face, particularly as federal aid covers a smaller share of college costs and most states give little in the way of financial grants to the poorest students. At the same time, for the poorest dependent students, far more family income was needed to pay for college in 2016 than even in 2008.

Margaret Cahalan, co-author of the report and Director of the Pell Institute, states:
“We must face the fact that the statistics we track in this report, show systemic inequality at every step of the college journey for low-income and first-generation students. These inequalities are unmasked and made more challenging by COVID-19 pandemic. As we recover and rebuild there is a need for bold ambitious new plans to seize this slightly more open moment as a portal to a more equitable, resilient and environmentally sustainable system.”
Co-author Laura Perna of the University of Pennsylvania Graduate School of Education states:
"Right now, low-income and first-generation students are deciding if they will be able to start college or return to college in the fall. This report spells out many of the extra hurdles these students faced to earning a degree even before the COVID-19 pandemic. With budget cuts looming, policymakers must prioritize these students because if they are forced off the path now, they are the least likely to make it back on."
The report found that:

  • More low-income students attend college, but. While college participation rates for the low-income students have increased substantially since 1990, from 32 percent to 51 percent in the lowest income quartile, it is still 24 percentage points lower than college participation rates in the highest income quartile. [Indicator 1a]
  • While enrollment has increased, systemic barriers persistently prevent high completion rates for low-income and first-generation students. Longitudinal studies reveal that for every 100 low-income and first-generation students entering college only 21 will have attained a bachelor’s degree by 6 years later compared with 66 percent of students who are not low-income and first-generation. [Indictor 5c(ii)]
  • Independent students are most at-risk of not completing their degrees. Six years after enrollment, about half (49 percent) of entering independent students were not enrolled and had not attained a degree or certificate. Nine percent had attained a bachelor’s degree, 13 percent an associate’s degree and 16 percent a certificate. [Indicator 5c(iv)]
  • When it comes to attending competitive colleges, socio-economic status (SES) matters most. High school students from the highest family SES quintile had 8 times the chance of going to a highly or moderately selective college as those in the lowest SES quintile (33 percent vs. 4 percent). [Indicator 2f]
  • Inverse relationship between the selectivity of the institution and the percent of students who receive Pell grants. Percent Pell ranged from 17 percent among the most selective to 67 among the for-profit sector. [Indicator 2e]
  • Pell Grant coverage of college costs has precipitously declined in since 1980. The maximum Pell Grant now covers a much smaller percentage of average college costs than it did decades ago. The value of the maximum Pell Grant peaked in 1975-76 when the grant covered about 67 percent of average college costs; in 2018-19 the maximum Pell Grant covered 25 percent. [Indicator 3b]
  • Net college costs take a bigger percentage of low-income families’ income Since 2008, the net price of higher education for dependent, full-time undergraduates as a percentage of family income has soared for the poorest students, going from 56 percent of family income in 2008 to 94 percent in 2016 for the lowest income quartile. [Indicator 4b (ii)]
  • Persistent Inequality by Family Income in Degree Attainment since 1970’s. Comparing 1970 to 2018, there has been little to no progress in the percentage of bachelor’s degrees awarded to the richest and poorest dependent students by age 24 with only 12 of bachelor’s degrees going to student in the lowest income quartile and almost three-fourths to students in the top half of the income distribution. [Indicator 5b]
  • Census data reveals a widening and serious divide among U.S. states in the percentage of young adults ages 25-34 with a bachelor’s degree or higher. States rates range from 23 percent in Nevada and New Mexico to 53 percent in Massachusetts, 47 percent in New Jersey and New York and 46 percent in Vermont. [Indicator 5f (v)]
  • U.S. share in degree attainment level plummets internationally. In 2002, the U.S. was 2nd in bachelor’s degree attainment among 30 countries. In 2018, it ranked 18th. [Indicator 6b]
  • Countries vary in degree attainment. Across nations, bachelor’s degree attainment ranged from 5 percent in South Africa to 56 percent in Lithuania. If Massachusetts were a country, it would be tied for second place internationally in bachelor’s degree attainment, equaling second-place Luxembourg, at 53 percent. [Indicator 6b]

Since 2015, the Indicators Reports have examined trends in higher education in the U.S. through the lens of equity, compiling historical trend data from the U.S. Census Bureau, the U.S. Department of Education and other public sources. This year, addressing the COVID-19 challenges and opportunities, the report also includes special essays exploring policy options to recover and rebuild a more equitable, resilient and environmentally sustainable higher education.

Suggested Citation: Cahalan, Margaret W., Perna, Laura W., Addison, Marisha, Murray, Chelsea, Patel, Pooja R., & Jiang, Nathan. (2020). Indicators of Higher Education Equity in the United States: 2020 Historical Trend Report. Washington, DC: The Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Higher Education, Council for Opportunity in Education (COE), and Alliance for Higher Education and Democracy of the University of Pennsylvania (PennAHEAD).